Most reviewed Italian restaurants in Puerto Vallarta

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Puerto Vallarta through these extensively reviewed and popular spots.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Search radius



Cafe Roma image
21
Cafe Roma
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Food was amazing!! The lasagna and calzones were very very good, nice fresh herbs and lots of cheese, yummy yummy yummy!!! Definitely recommend this place 👍👍👍👍
$ $$$
4.40 (318 reviews)
A Taste Of Italy image
22
A Taste Of Italy
Italian restaurant
👍👍 ["Awesome burgers and friendly service, very reasonable prices. $3 margaritas are super. Book ahead for tables especially on Wednesdays when they have home made lasagna. This is a favorite place for locals.",null,[0,206]]
4.40 (306 reviews)
Tre Piatti image
23
Tre Piatti
Italian restaurant
👍 Overall a nice experience. Service was excellent - - prompt but not obtrusive, professional but friendly. Both dishes I had were prepared and presented well. A nice selection of wine. While I would go back, I felt that the price was a little high for what you got, especially since the setting was no...
4.60 (259 reviews)
Di Vino Dante image
24
Di Vino Dante
Spanish restaurant
😠 Beautiful space. Nice services. Place is empty in busy season when everything else is full. Should have been a sign! WiFi sucks! Big story about owner falling in love with Mexican wine, but Mexican wine list is all the mediocre. Nothing worth paying money to drink. BIG fail. Another sign of imp...
$$ $$
4.70 (250 reviews)
IL PESCE - Cucina di Mare image
25
IL PESCE - Cucina di Mare
Italian restaurant
👍👍 IL Pesce is legit. A great place, quaint and with great vibes. Service is extremely kind and professional. This is a small place with big food. Not over the top big. But big in quality, big in not trying too hard but just doing. Doing what they love and what they do well. The pastas were great. The...
4.80 (237 reviews)
La Notte Pizzería Restaurant&Bar image
26
La Notte Pizzería Restaurant&Bar
Pizza restaurant
👍👍 Still one of my all time favorites in PV. New location down the block, even better pizza. Excellent pizza, some of the best we've ever had! Rafael and his staff are excellent and will make you feel welcome. Watch them hand toss, top and wood fire your pizza. Great salads, pastas and the best limonad...
4.80 (230 reviews)
Ortensia Trattoria image
27
Ortensia Trattoria
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Excellent Italian restaurant in Puerto Vallarta. A bit of a walk up a hill, but the hike was worth it for the views. Get a table outside if possible. Huge portions - we could not come close to finishing the food. We had to take a lot back to our Airbnb. Friendly, fast service. Great wine. The pizza...
$$ $$
4.30 (164 reviews)
THE SEAHORSE CUCINA BAR & LOUNGE image
28
THE SEAHORSE CUCINA BAR & LOUNGE
Italian restaurant
👍👍 wonderful room, lots of light, sunset viewing of course. delicious food. Raúl is a wonderful host. A bit of Italy right in downtown Puerto Vallarta. unexpected
4.60 (156 reviews)
Wonderland Coffee image
29
Wonderland Coffee
Restaurant
😐 El lugar está muy bonito, el personal muy amable. Solo que las bebidas y las pizzas no son nada memorables.....probamos frapuchino Moka, Chai y Wonderland con licor....se ven bonitos pero su sabor no es espectacular, la pizza de chicharron y de peperonni tampoco. Aunque es un local nuevo y tal vez v...
4.40 (148 reviews)
Magna Magna image
30
Magna Magna
Italian restaurant
👍👍 Luca, the owner/ chef makes all of his pasta from scratch. He is very gracious abd obliging. Today I had 1/2 a Caprese Salad, which has his homemade pesto on top along with fresh homemade bread and dipping sauce. I also had a slice of mushroom pizza...delicious topping and crispy crust. My favorit...
4.50 (129 reviews)
San Pietro image
31
San Pietro
Italian restaurant
😐 Pasta is good. The pizza is terrible, it's like Bisquick or something. I have a pizza oven at home and if I could speak Spanish I would go back there and teach them how to make a proper Italian pizza. But they may not have a hot enough oven.
4.50 (92 reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Last updated:
( )