Most reviewed Italian restaurants in Sicily

Explore the city's most talked-about destinations, sorted by the number of reviews. The higher the position on the list, the greater the number of reviews for each place. Discover the pulse of Sicily through these extensively reviewed and popular spots.

Sort results by

Best  
🔥
Top rated  
🏆
Most reviewed  
🤩
Hidden gems  
💎
Worst rated  
🤬
Recently discovered  
🆕

Categories



Trattoria del Cavaliere image
1
Trattoria del Cavaliere
Italian restaurant
Sicilian-style pasta & seafood in a long-standing restaurant with relaxed rooms & a terrace.
$ $$$
4.20 (9.4K reviews)
Ancient Saint Francis Focaccia Shop image
2
Ancient Saint Francis Focaccia Shop
Sicilian restaurant
🫤 The best thing about the restaurant was the location. Located at the S. Francisco church piazza , I really wanted to like this restaurant. The location was beautiful ( a wedding took place before dinner) and the ambiance was perfect BUT.... the service was spotty and inconsistent at best. NOW...
3.90 (8.7K reviews)
Trattoria Al Ferro di Cavallo image
3
Trattoria Al Ferro di Cavallo
Italian restaurant
Longstanding, rustic venue with outdoor tables, dishing up classic Sicilian pasta & seafood dishes.
4.00 (5.7K reviews)
Il Borgo di Federico image
4
Il Borgo di Federico
Restaurant
Bustling trattoria featuring a classic pasta, seafood & meat menu, as well as casual patio seating.
$ $$$
4.00 (5K reviews)
Pizzeria Frida image
5
Pizzeria Frida
Pizza restaurant
Bustling restaurant with a terrace & a colorful Frida Kahlo theme, dishing up hearty standards.
4.40 (4.3K reviews)
Caseificio Borderi image
6
Caseificio Borderi
Italian restaurant
Neighborhood joint whipping up large homemade sandwiches made with locally sourced ingredients.
$ $$$
4.70 (4.2K reviews)
Osteria dei Sapori Perduti image
7
Osteria dei Sapori Perduti
Sicilian restaurant
👍👍 Thank you for the great food! I can only recommend it to everyone if they want real Sicilian flavors! The staff is kind and helpful, the restaurant is very clean!🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
$$ $$
4.30 (4.2K reviews)
A Putia image
8
A Putia
Sicilian restaurant
Antipasti, pasta & robust Sicilian mains in a rustic-chic space with colorful decor.
$$ $$
4.60 (3.9K reviews)
Pizzeria Villa Zuccaro image
9
Pizzeria Villa Zuccaro
Pizza restaurant
Charming restaurant in a 17th-century villa, offering Sicilian dishes & pizza, plus a leafy patio.
$$ $$
4.50 (3.8K reviews)
Osteria Mangia e Bevi image
10
Osteria Mangia e Bevi
Sicilian restaurant
Stone walls at a venue serving Sicilian classics like fried pasta with aubergines & fish dishes.
4.00 (3.4K reviews)
Ristorante Antichi Sapori image
11
Ristorante Antichi Sapori
Restaurant
Traditional local dishes like couscous & almond-based pesto, plus fish, in a cozy taverna.
4.50 (3.1K reviews)
Rosticceria Da Cristina image
12
Rosticceria Da Cristina
Restaurant
👍👍 Amazing Arancini’s at a good price. The best in Sicily! We had the classic meat one and the pistachio one. Both were very good, hot and tasty. Only downside is that they make you pay for forks however the traditional way is to eat with your hands
$ $$$
4.50 (3.1K reviews)
Pizzeria Schiticchio image
13
Pizzeria Schiticchio
Pizza restaurant
Funky restaurant set in a stone, cave-like spot offering pizzas, burgers & drinks.
$$ $$
4.50 (3.1K reviews)
Osteria Lo Bianco sede storica image
14
Osteria Lo Bianco sede storica
Restaurant
Lively fixture with checkered tablecloths offering homestyle Sicilian soups, stews & salads.
4.10 (3.1K reviews)
Antichi Proverbi STORICO image
15
Antichi Proverbi STORICO
Pizza restaurant
😠 It's closed. Was closed on Friday 7th of April at dining hours
4.50 (3K reviews)
Nonna Dora image
16
Nonna Dora
Sicilian restaurant
Buzzing local landmark offering hearty regional plates in a traditionally furnished dining room.
4.40 (3K reviews)
Cutilisci image
17
Cutilisci
Italian restaurant
Pizza, Sicilian seafood & granita, plus beer & wine, in a bright space with a seafront terrace.
$$ $$
4.10 (2.9K reviews)
La Terrazza Del Barone image
18
La Terrazza Del Barone
Italian restaurant
👍 ["The food was amazing, we ordered the set of mussels in sauce and two different pasta. White wine as well. The prices are good. What I liked not that much was lard that has to be a bacon and I hoped to have it well fried not like boiled ( it was not boiled, but fried that lightly that felt like boi...
$ $$$
4.10 (2.9K reviews)
Sicilia's Cafe de Mar image
19
Sicilia's Cafe de Mar
Mediterranean restaurant
Airy venue for aperitifs & Sicilian food, with floor-to-ceiling windows & a terrace facing the sea.
$$ $$
4.00 (2.8K reviews)
Lido Azzurro image
20
Lido Azzurro
Beach club
Long-running, upscale beach zone with sun loungers, cabanas, a swimming pool & a bar/restaurant.
4.00 (2.8K reviews)
Tip: Click on the rating to open it on Google Maps




Categories